Paycheck Calculator (Federal + NY)
Calculator
Inputs
How NYC stacks up
A New Yorker living in the five boroughs at $95,000 single keeps roughly 65 percent of the gross. The same salary in Texas or Florida (no state income tax) keeps closer to 73 percent. That is an $8,000-a-year gap on the same paycheck. It does not mean New York is wrong – it just means the difference is real, and shows up every two weeks.
The combined NY State + NYC rate the calculator defaults to (9.876 percent) is a reasonable midpoint for middle-income earners. The actual marginal rates climb to 10.9 percent state plus 3.876 percent city at the top. NY tax tables.
Pre-tax dollars are not the same as after-tax
Every dollar you put into a Traditional 401(k), HSA, or commuter benefit comes off the top before federal and (in most cases) state tax. For an NYC earner in the 24 percent federal bracket plus 10 percent state plus 3.8 percent city, that is roughly 38 cents of tax avoided per pre-tax dollar. A $200/check HSA contribution actually only costs the worker about $124 in take-home pay.
The biggest under-used tool is the commuter benefit (Section 132). NYC workers can put up to $325/month for transit on a pre-tax basis – about $4,500/year off the top. Most companies offer it; most employees never sign up.
Where the calculator falls short
It assumes the standard deduction, no itemized deductions, no dependent credits, no bonuses, and no equity compensation. For higher earners with RSUs, ISOs, or significant non-W-2 income, the picture changes – and the W-4 you filed in onboarding usually has the wrong number of allowances by year five. We see that on most business owner returns and on every executive transitioning between firms.
W-4 not matching reality?
If your refund or balance due is more than a couple of thousand either way, the W-4 is the wrong shape. We fix this every January for new clients.